The briefs
Major briefs
Mortality and morbidity: mothers and babies
Most of these deaths can be prevented.
Severe complications keep rising.
What happens to the mother happens to the baby.
- 18–33 deaths per 100,000 live births (17.9 in 2024 to 32.9 in 2021)
- ~650–1,200 maternal deaths annually (649 in 2024 to 1,205 in 2021)
- 84% of pregnancy-related deaths deemed preventable
- Black maternal mortality 2–3x higher
- ~35,300 severe maternal morbidity cases during delivery hospitalizations (101.1 per 10,000 delivery stays) · AHRQ HCUP, 2021
- Rising over two decades
- 5.5 infant deaths per 1,000 live births (2024)
- ~10% preterm birth rate
- 1.5–2.5 per 1,000 babies with brain injury from low oxygen around birth
- Lower hemorrhage rates in birth center models
- Fewer surgical complications
- Reduced long-term placenta accreta burden due to lower repeat cesareans
- 6.3% preterm birth in Strong Start birth centers vs 8.5% in similar Medicaid care (CMS Strong Start evaluation, 2018)
- Comparable neonatal mortality in appropriately screened low-risk populations
- Lower NICU admission rates in physiologic birth settings
Sources: CDC, Pregnancy-Related Deaths: Data From Maternal Mortality Review Committees, 2017–2019; CDC / NCHS; CMS Strong Start evaluation (2018); Kurinczuk et al. 2010; Graham et al. 2008
Insurance-led standards and the loss of informed refusal
Payers and liability fear set the standard of care.
The standard becomes the protocol.
The protocol leaves no room for no.
- $28,998 average cost of pregnancy, birth and postpartum care with a cesarean, vs $15,712 with a vaginal birth (employer plans, 2021–2023)
Sources: Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker (2025)
Refusal to integrate
Many systems will not work with community Midwives.
Supervision rules give one institution a veto.
A transfer becomes a confrontation, not a hand-off.
Families pay for that delay.
Sources: Congress.gov; CMS. The bill and program details are on Legal Watch.
Criminalization of community midwifery
Where the only lawful path is a license, traditional practice becomes illegal.
Midwives are investigated and charged.
Families lose the attendant they chose.
Sources: State statutes and bills. Details are on Legal Watch.
Supporting briefs
Consolidation and closures
Maternity units close when they stop paying.
Consolidated systems close them first.
A maternity care desert is where consolidation ends.
- More than half of U.S. counties have no hospital with labor and delivery.
- 146 rural hospitals have stopped delivering babies since the end of 2020, or announced they will. More than two a month.
- Only 40% of rural hospitals still deliver babies.
- About 27% of rural OB units are gone since 2011.
- Only four states have lost none: Delaware, Hawaii, Massachusetts and Utah.
Sources: CHQPR, Stopping the Loss of Rural Maternity Care; Chartis 2026; March of Dimes, Nowhere to Go (2026)
Cesareans and interventions
Labor runs on protocol.
Interventions stack. Surgery follows.
One cesarean shapes every birth after it.
- 1 in 4 first-time, low-risk mothers (26.6%, 2024)
- Repeat cesarean likely after primary
- Placenta accreta risk >6% (6.74%) at a sixth or later cesarean · Silver et al., Obstet Gynecol 2006
- 24.9% → 34.5% of births induced, 2016 to 2024 · CDC / NCHS Data Brief 554
- 43% walked once labor was underway; 21% ate · Listening to Mothers III, 2013
- 29% fewer cesareans for upright, moving mothers. “No justification” for restricting food in low-risk labor · Cochrane, 2013
- Pitocin, a “high-alert” drug · ISMP 2024
- 2x episodes of contractions too fast, in 50,335 births · Heuser, AJOG 2013
- 20–29% drop in babies’ oxygen · Simpson & James, AJOG 2008
- 6% cesarean rate for 15,574 low-risk women in labor at 79 U.S. birth centers, 2007–2010 · Stapleton et al., J Midwifery Womens Health 2013 (National Birth Center Study II)
- Birth center cesarean: 8.7% primary, 17.5% total, vs 21.7% and 29.0% in similar Medicaid care · CMS Strong Start evaluation, 2018
Sources: CDC / NCHS; CMS Strong Start evaluation (2018); Listening to Mothers III; Cochrane; ISMP; Heuser et al.; Simpson & James
Mistreatment and loss of informed consent
Consent has become a form.
Pressure replaces choice.
Mothers carry it home.
- Up to 30% of women view their birth as traumatic · Schobinger et al., Frontiers in Psychiatry 2020
Sources: Schobinger et al. 2020
Mandated reporting misuse
A lawful refusal should never be a report.
When refusal is coded as risk, the reporting line is crossed for the wrong reason.
There is no accountability when it is misused.
Sources: Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (ACF)
Postpartum mental health and breastfeeding
The first year decides a great deal.
Surgery, trauma and short contact cost mothers and babies.
- Postpartum depression: 1 in 8 mothers
- Mental health conditions leading cause of maternal death in first year
- 1 in 25 develop PTSD after birth
- 85% initiate breastfeeding
- <30% exclusively breastfeeding at 6 months
- Continuity model with extended postpartum contact
- Increased early detection of mood disorders
- Reduced traumatic birth exposure due to lower intervention cascade
- 92.9% breastfeeding at discharge in Strong Start birth centers · Alliman et al., Birth 2019
- Higher exclusive breastfeeding at discharge
- Reduced delayed lactogenesis due to lower surgical birth rates
Sources: CDC / NCHS; Yildiz, Ayers & Phillips 2017; Alliman et al. 2019 (Strong Start)
Why no safe harbor law covers Midwives
Safe harbor laws protect unlicensed practitioners who disclose and do no harm.
That gap is where Midwives fall.
Sources: National Health Freedom Coalition, Safe Harbor Laws
Projected national impact
If integrated midwifery care reached 40% of low-risk births, we could prevent about 87,000 primary C-sections each year and nearly 500,000 in five years, translating into tens of thousands fewer surgical complications and transfusions, fewer NICU admissions and delayed breastfeeding starts, and a measurable reduction in severe maternal morbidity and preventable maternal deaths tied to operative birth. NATBR projection.
Sources: U.S. Births & Cesarean Rates (CDC / NCHS); Preventability of Maternal Death (MMRC Report); Birth Center / Midwifery Model Outcomes (CMS Strong Start evaluation; Alliman et al. 2019); Birth Trauma (Schobinger et al. 2020); Silver et al. 2006; MacDorman & Declercq 2019; AHRQ HCUP; Yildiz et al. 2017; Kurinczuk 2010; Graham 2008.
Source library
- CDC / NCHS, Births: Final Data for 2024
- CDC / NCHS Data Brief No. 554 (induction, 2026)
- AHRQ HCUP Statistical Brief #312
- CDC Vital Signs, MMWR 2023 (mistreatment)
- Maternal Mortality Review Committees (MMRC), 2017–2019
- CMS Strong Start for Mothers and Newborns Evaluation (2018)
- Stapleton et al., National Birth Center Study II, J Midwifery Womens Health 2013
- Alliman et al., Strong Start in birth centers, Birth 2019
- Listening to Mothers III, full report (2013)
- Silver et al., Obstet Gynecol 2006 (repeat cesareans)
- MacDorman & Declercq, Birth 2019 (out-of-hospital births)
- Schobinger et al., Frontiers in Psychiatry 2020 (traumatic birth)
- AHRQ HCUP Statistical Brief #312, Trends in Severe Maternal Morbidity, 2016–2021 (2024)
- CDC / NCHS, Infant Mortality in the United States, 2024
- Listening to Mothers III (2013)
- Cochrane: upright positions (2013)
- Cochrane: food and drink in labor (2013)
- ISMP High-Alert Medications (2024)
- Heuser et al., AJOG 2013
- Simpson & James, AJOG 2008
- Kurinczuk et al. 2010
- Graham et al., AJOG 2008
- Yildiz, Ayers & Phillips 2017
- PNHP, Moral Injury in Medicine
- March of Dimes, Nowhere to Go (2026)
- Chartis, 2026 Rural Health State of the State
- Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker, Health costs associated with pregnancy, childbirth, and infant care (2025)
- CHQPR, Stopping the Loss of Rural Maternity Care
Next: the solution.
The visionThe case for change · Contact info@natbr.org