Problem 1 · Money
Erosion of Choice Through Insurance-Led, Monopolized Systems
Most families don’t experience “freedom to choose.” They experience what their insurance network permits and what consolidated hospital systems offer.
When a few entities control reimbursement, access, and policy, choice becomes a marketing word, not a reality.
How choice gets quietly erased:
- Network lock-in: Families are steered into limited provider networks, often excluding midwives or out-of-hospital options.
- Reimbursement incentives: Systems are rewarded for volume and intervention, not time-intensive, relationship-based care.
- Hospital consolidation: Mergers reduce competition and standardize policies across regions, leaving families with one dominant system.
- Administrative “policies” become law: Hospital protocols override individualized risk assessment and patient preference.
- Coverage gaps: Even when midwifery is legal, lack of coverage prices out most working families.
Money: from payment to a desert
Who pays decides what care exists.
Insurance and Medicaid.
Payers set the networks and the fee schedules.
Procedures and volume are paid. Time with a mother is not.
This leads to health systems built around what pays.
Consolidated systems.
Health systems consolidate to secure those contracts.
One owner writes the rules for a whole region.
Because there is no competitor, its policy becomes the only policy.
98%of U.S. births are in a hospital (98.4%, 2017) · NCHS birth data, MacDorman & Declercq, Birth 2019Administrative policy becomes the rule.
Policy is written once and applied in every hospital the system owns.
Deviating means liability, so staff follow the order set.
This leads to units judged by margin, not by need.
Unprofitable units go first.
Low-volume maternity units lose money under that payment model.
The system closes them first.
Because the nearest unit is gone, families travel farther for care.
331rural hospitals stopped OB care, 2011–2024 · Chartis 2026~60%were the county’s only birthing facility; +25 min to care · March of Dimes 2026A maternity care desert.
When the nearest unit is 45 minutes away, every minute counts.
Families take whatever care is left.
This leads to the choice problem: the mother arrives with one option, and little say in it.
5.8Mwomen and 358,000 infants without full access · March of Dimes 2026Consolidation removes choice.
Increases choice. Home, birth center and hospital work as one system.
Barriers push the midwife out.
Removes barriers: a legal pathway, coverage, no veto rules.
Money: from more choice to stronger communities
How the fix ripples through the system, step by step.
More places to give birth.
Expanded legal space increases access to home birth, birth centers, and independent midwifery practices.
Because families have somewhere else to go, systems must earn their trust.
Lower barriers.
Certificate-of-need repeal and licensure restraint lower entry barriers and operating costs.
This leads to new practices opening where units closed.
Competition returns.
More competition shifts the market from compliance-driven care to outcome- and relationship-driven care.
Because outcomes now win families, payers follow.
Coverage follows.
Insurance and reimbursement models adapt to a broader provider base.
This leads to coverage for every kind of Midwife.
Every lane grows.
Demand rises across the spectrum: CNMs, CPMs, licensed midwives, traditional midwives, doulas.
Revenue and professional autonomy increase across midwifery models, not just one lane.
Care comes back close to home.
Problem 2 · Choice
Eradication of the Midwife & Midwifery Care
Traditional and community midwifery did not disappear because it “failed.” It was displaced by policy, economics, and institutional control.
In many states, midwifery is either structurally blocked or pushed into dependency models that eliminate true independent care.
How eradication happens in real life:
- No legal pathway: Some states offer no viable licensure route for community-based midwives, creating de facto illegality.
- Criminalization and enforcement: Midwives are investigated, charged, fined, or pressured into stopping through board referrals and hospital complaints.
- Institutional gatekeeping: “Collaboration” or “supervision” requirements can function as veto power over practice.
- Insurance exclusion: When midwifery isn’t reimbursed, access becomes a cash-only luxury, not a public health option.
- Regulation as suppression: Rules are framed as “safety,” while excluding the very model proven to reduce intervention for low-risk women.
- Cultural conditioning: The public is trained to view birth as inherently dangerous outside institutions, even when outcomes data supports midwifery-led care for low-risk populations.
Choice: from consent to a report
The framework determines the menu.
Order sets, EMR prompts, defensive charting.
These tools decide what gets discussed at the bedside.
The physician works inside them, not above them.
This leads to a short list of options.
45%of physicians often feel unable to give the best care; 68% distressed · PNHP survey, 1,207 physiciansOnly sanctioned options.
The mother hears only what policy allows.
Signing the form becomes the decision.
Because the alternatives were never offered, saying no looks abnormal.
13–15%of mothers report pressure for induction or cesarean · Listening to Mothers III, 2013Coded as risk behavior.
Ethics consults. Administrative review. Mandated reporting.
No accountability for misuse.
This leads families to learn that a question can bring a caseworker.
Choice becomes conditional.
Some families fear the hospital when they need it most.
They comply, or they stay home and delay a transfer.
This is where the midwife is blamed, and pushed out.
Choice: how the midwife is pushed out
Blocked. Excluded. One path left.
No pathway. Criminalization.
Without a legal route, a practicing Midwife is exposed to charges.
Board referrals and complaints do the rest.
This leads to fewer Midwives, working quietly.
Veto rules. No coverage.
Supervision rules let one institution say no.
Insurance will not pay.
Because care is cash-only and permission-based, families cannot reach it.
Single-path authority over birth.
The hospital becomes the only legal, covered option.
This leads every birth back through the cascades above.
The better outcomes disappear.
The lower intervention rates of midwifery care never reach most families.
Internal System Structure and Its Impact on Informed Consent
In hospital-based systems, informed consent operates within predefined pathways. Standardized order sets, risk stratification protocols, electronic medical record prompts, and defensive documentation requirements narrow the scope of what is discussed. The provider is not functioning solely as a clinician; they are functioning within an institutional risk architecture. That architecture prioritizes liability containment and regulatory compliance.
The result is that consent becomes procedural rather than deliberative. Families are often presented with institutionally sanctioned options, not the full spectrum of physiologically reasonable alternatives. Even when clinicians personally support lower-intervention care, they operate inside policy constraints that limit deviation from established protocols.
Thus, informed consent in highly regulated systems becomes structurally shaped. The framework determines the menu.
Structural Effects on Parental Choice, Informed Refusal, and Mandated Reporting
The same internal structures that shape consent also influence how refusal is interpreted.
Within institutional maternity systems, deviation from recommended care can trigger escalation pathways. Documentation protocols, ethics consults, administrative review, and in some cases mandated reporting mechanisms are embedded into the system design. Refusal is not treated as a neutral exercise of autonomy; it is often coded as risk behavior.
This creates a subtle but powerful shift: parental choice becomes conditional upon institutional approval. When informed refusal intersects with liability exposure, providers may feel compelled to document in ways that protect the institution rather than facilitate collaborative care.
In high-surveillance environments, the threshold for involving social services can narrow. Families who decline specific interventions may encounter increased scrutiny, not necessarily because of individualized clinical harm, but because refusal disrupts standardized compliance pathways.
Over time, this dynamic alters behavior. Families internalize the limits of acceptable dissent. Providers internalize the boundaries of permissible flexibility.
The system, not the individual, becomes the ultimate arbiter of decision legitimacy.
Lost choice changes the climate inside hospitals. Protocols win over evidence.
Forces policy to match evidence.
Mandated reporting is misused, with no accountability.
Forces accountability. Reports rest on evidence of harm, not a lawful choice.
Choice: from one path to many
How the fix ripples through the system, step by step.
One path ends.
Protection of traditional midwifery restores pluralism and ends single-path authority over birth.
Because there is more than one path, consent has to mean something.
Consent is real again.
Informed consent and informed refusal normalize, reducing coercive escalation and unnecessary reporting.
This leads to reports that rest on facts.
Reports rest on harm.
A lawful choice is not a report.
Misuse has consequences, so reporting is kept for real harm.
This leads families to trust the system again.
Families speak up.
They come to the hospital when they need it, without fear.
Transfers happen early. Communities keep their Midwives.
Next: how we get there.
The visionThe case for change · Contact info@natbr.org